Jesus Christ Superstar @ Capitol Theatre, Eora/Sydney – 4 December 2024

I’m easing myself back into work thanks to the wonders of speech-to-text technology. First on my to-do list was sharing my thoughts on the wonderful production of Jesus Christ Superstar playing in Eora/Sydney at the moment. I had tickets to the show the day after my car accident, so I was a bit sore and sorry as I bundled myself onto the train, but I’m so glad I pushed through the pain. I’ve seen three or four productions of Superstar over the years, and this was definitely among the best.

I felt excitement bubbling up as the familiar “Overture” began. Then with “Heaven on Their Minds” we were introduced to the incredible Javon King as Judas. What a great voice he has. What a presence. I didn’t know him before this production, but I will watch his career closely from now on. The entire cast was sensational. The casting of Mahalia Barnes as Mary was one of the key draw cards for me, and she did not disappoint. She brought such a beautiful warmth and heart to the role, and what a voice she has. I was also really excited to see Reuben Kaye playing Herod. He was brilliant. Honestly he may be my favourite Herod ever. He had just the right blend of humour and malice. My parents weren’t familiar with him but they walked away fans. I was also really impressed by Peter Murphy’s Pilate. Unfortunately Michael Paynter didn’t appear in our matinee. While the understudy was great, I was really looking forward to his Jesus. I also wonder whether Michael’s voice may have contrasted better with Javon’s. JC simply works better when you can hear the difference between Jesus and Judas.

This production feels so new and fresh. The music doesn’t seem to age. The energy of the cast is palpable. I also really liked artistic choices like bringing the microphones into the scenes and having the crucifix as a key part of the set. The use of glitter was very effective in places, although I’m not sure it was as powerful as it should have been while Jesus received his lashes. Overall, I think the team behind this version of JC has done an incredible job. Whether you’re a long-time fan like many or new to the musical, make sure you don’t miss it.

Jesus Christ Superstar will play at the Capitol Theatre until January 26. It’ll then head to Boorloo/Perth in February and play Naarm/Melbourne in March before travelling to Meeanjin/Brisbane in June.